State pensioners born before 1953 are at risk of incurring fines from HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) despite adhering to published guidelines when completing their tax returns. This issue came to light after a concerned pensioner reached out to tax expert Mike Warburton, highlighting confusion over how to correctly declare state pension income.
In a letter to the Telegraph, the pensioner expressed frustration: “How are pensioners expected to accurately complete self-assessment returns and verify the tax on their state pension when HMRC’s instructions don’t align with the law? I even asked the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) to collaborate with HMRC to provide pensioners with a certificate—similar to a P60—showing the correct taxable pension amount each year, but they declined.”
The pensioner further questioned the calculation method, pointing out that the new state pension entitlement begins on the first Monday of the tax year. “To calculate taxable income for a given tax year, must I count all Mondays from April 6 to the following April 5? This method conflicts with HMRC’s tax return notes, and I find it unreasonable for elderly pensioners to navigate such complexity.”
READ MORE: Three Major Universal Credit Changes Now in Effect
READ MORE: Tesco Introduces 8am-5pm Park & Pause Bays with Free Drinks from April 11
The “new” state pension applies to men and women born before 1953, and this calculation ambiguity has concerned Mike Warburton for years. He has also appealed to HMRC for clearer guidance.
HMRC warns that penalties may result from late tax returns, late payments, inaccurate returns, or failure to maintain proper records. According to Mike, from a strict legal perspective, the calculation should apply the old accrual rate to the days between April 6 and the following Monday, then the new accrual rate for the remainder of the tax year. However, this legal approach conflicts with official HMRC guidance.
HMRC instructs pensioners to use the Pension Service’s letter to determine weekly state pension amounts, adding up entitlement from April 6, 2024, to April 5, 2025, and report this total in box 8 of the tax return. The guidance clarifies that the taxable amount is the weekly entitlement figure—not the number of payments received. This involves calculating one week at the old rate plus 51 weeks at the new rate.
Mike advises pensioners to follow HMRC’s method despite its discrepancy with the strict legal interpretation, aiming to avoid penalties while awaiting clearer official resolutions.