Over a month has passed since Birmingham Labour experienced a severe blow in the local elections, resulting in the loss of council control after 14 years. The party’s leader, John Cotton, lost his seat, and the number of Labour councillors plummeted dramatically from 65 in 2022 to just 17.
This catastrophic decline unfolded against a backdrop of multiple challenges, including the ongoing bins strike, the conflict in Gaza, and growing dissatisfaction with Sir Keir Starmer’s leadership at the national level. Consequently, Birmingham’s political landscape shifted dramatically, with a new coalition of Liberal Democrats, Greens, and independents assuming control of the council.
Labour opted not to join this coalition. Their newly appointed leader, Councillor Nicky Brennan, pledged last month to “reflect carefully on the result” and “serve residents constructively from the opposition benches.”
READ MORE: New Maternity Leave Rules in England Highlight Financial Challenges for Working Mothers
READ MORE: West Midlands mayor scrutiny overhaul criticised as ‘Orwellian’ amidst funding and accountability concerns
Despite this stance, internal unrest has persisted, culminating in the recent departure of two Labour councillors within a week. Diane Donaldson, representing Hodge Hill and Bromford, was the first to resign. She cited being instructed to vote alongside the Reform group at a full council meeting, as well as dissatisfaction with national handling of the Gaza situation and issues with accountability and leadership within Labour.
Following her footsteps, Councillor Majid Mahmood, also representing Hodge Hill and Bromford and a former cabinet member, quit the party last Friday. He expressed “serious concerns about the current state” of Birmingham Labour and publicly conveyed his disappointment that Labour was excluded from the city’s new left-wing coalition.
Mahmood’s resignation letter detailed his unease over expectations for Labour to support the appointment of Reform group councillors to key roles, stating, “My views no longer fit comfortably within a Labour Party. Ultimately, the Labour Party has left me, not the other way around.” He vowed to continue representing his constituents alongside Diane Donaldson, advocating for the core values that originally motivated his public service.
In response, Birmingham Labour accused Mahmood of actively “undermining the Labour group and its new leadership.” A party insider defended the group’s unity, saying Mahmood “simply jumped before he was pushed” and that his departure would allow strengthened efforts to rebuild Labour in the city free from what they described as “his ego.”
The Labour spokesperson criticized Mahmood for declining to stand for group leader when given the opportunity. They emphasized Labour councillors’ commitment to working collectively for Birmingham residents and reaffirmed the party’s dedication to providing robust and constructive opposition.
Similarly, regarding Donaldson’s resignation, the Labour group expressed disappointment at her decision, especially so soon after the election. They reiterated their intention to continue holding the new administration accountable in line with Labour principles.
With these resignations, Birmingham Labour’s representation in the council now stands at 15 seats—fewer than the Reform group, Greens, and Conservatives. As they navigate this turbulent period, leader Nicky Brennan and the Labour group face the pressing challenge of reflecting on their setbacks and rebuilding party cohesion and influence within Birmingham’s evolving political environment.