The Coach & Horses Inn, a historic Midland pub dating back to 1787, stands at a crossroads as its landlord warns it may close this year without urgent government intervention. Nestled on the border of Alvechurch and Birmingham, this family-owned country pub, which predates the French Revolution, is facing severe financial pressures that threaten its survival.
Landlord Gary Meads spoke candidly about the challenges facing the hospitality industry, highlighting that escalating costs and policy decisions have made it “unlikely” that his pub will survive through 2026. Despite widespread criticism over recent government budget measures—particularly concerning business rates reform that many say will increase costs for pubs—Meads believes the real solution lies elsewhere.
“The help we need is a VAT cut, as simple as that,” Meads told BirminghamLive. “It’s an immediate fix. It eases cash flow pressure and allows us to hire more staff and reinvest in the business, which ultimately benefits the government through increased economic activity.”
READ MORE: Dismay as Key Disability Access Upgrades Axed at Birmingham’s Small Heath Station
READ MORE: BT to Retire Landlines Permanently in 132 Locations - Complete List Inside
Currently, pubs face a 20% VAT rate on food and drink sales, unlike supermarkets which pay zero VAT on food. This discrepancy gives supermarkets an advantage, allowing them to sell alcohol cheaper and drawing business away from traditional pubs.
Meads also called for a reversal of class 4 National Insurance contributions, arguing these combined taxes put pubs under unfair financial strain. “If things don’t change, pubs like mine will disappear,” he warned. “I honestly don’t think I’ll see this year out if conditions don’t improve.”
Support for a VAT cut is echoed by industry leaders such as Wetherspoons boss Tim Martin, who argues a reduction to 12.5% is essential to stop the ongoing closure of pubs, bars, and restaurants.
Meads expressed frustration with political leadership on both sides of the aisle. “I’m not here to bash Labour alone—the Conservatives weren’t much better—but the last 18 months under Rachel Reeves’ policies have cost me about £50,000 a year, which was my wage,” he explained. “I’m now forced to take money out of the business just to survive, despite there being little optimism for the future.”
With no relief in sight, and business rates reforms yet to take effect, the future of the Coach & Horses Inn hangs in the balance, symbolizing the broader struggle of British pubs caught between tradition and economic reality.