Harvey Elliott’s struggle to secure regular playing time at Aston Villa continues, leaving fans and pundits alike questioning his fit within Unai Emery’s squad. The 22-year-old England international was once again an unused substitute during Villa’s 2-1 Europa League win over Young Boys, marking another frustrating outing for the Liverpool loanee.
Stephen Warnock, former Liverpool and Villa defender, believes Elliott has the talent to break into Emery’s plans but highlights a key issue: Elliott’s lack of a clearly defined best position. Warnock told Birmingham Live, “He’s a brilliant footballer and naturally gifted, but what is his best position? That’s been his downfall.” He pointed out that Elliott has shown versatility, but this has also worked against him as Emery struggles to find a consistent role for the young midfielder.
Elliott’s limited appearances—just five across all competitions, including three in the Premier League—have stirred speculation about his loan future. If Elliott reaches 10 appearances, Villa is obligated to sign him permanently for £35 million, a clause that adds another layer of complexity to his situation.
READ MORE: Labour’s Budget Ends Tax Relief for Home Workers in England from April
READ MORE: Lloyds Bank Expands £1 Billion Lending Boost for First-Time Buyers, Including Self-Employed
Warnock also discussed the possibility of the Liverpool loanee returning to Anfield in January if the situation doesn’t improve. “If come January, he’s still not playing and there’s a way out, I’m sure he’ll consider it because he wants to play,” Warnock said.
Villa manager Unai Emery addressed the situation, emphasizing squad competition and Elliott’s training efforts. “We now have a lot of matches. We must focus on each match with the players we have now. He is training very well every day,” Emery stated, leaving the door open but non-committal on Elliott’s role.
Despite the challenges, Warnock believes Elliott will keep striving to win over Emery, even if it requires patience and perseverance. “The hardest part is not trying too hard… It’s got to be a natural evolution. He’s good enough to do it, maybe it just needs a bit more time,” Warnock concluded.
With the January transfer window approaching, Elliott’s future at Villa remains uncertain, but his talent and determination might yet turn the tide in his favor.