Campaigners are demanding urgent changes to how the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) assesses claimants with invisible and fluctuating symptoms under the Personal Independence Payment (PIP) system. Ross Barrett of the MS Society highlights critical flaws that disproportionately affect people living with conditions like multiple sclerosis (MS).
PIP is designed to support disabled individuals in maintaining employment by providing financial assistance based on the level of help they require with daily activities. However, the current assessment process often fails to accurately reflect the realities faced by those with fluctuating conditions. To address these issues, the Labour Party government has initiated the Timms Review.
Barrett warns, “PIP’s rigid criteria, particularly the ‘50% rule’ which disregards impairments present for less than half of the time, exclude many who experience severe but intermittent symptoms. This results in significant under-recognition of the challenges people with MS face.”
READ MORE: DWP Urged to End Mandatory PIP Reassessments for Long-Term Conditions Like MS
READ MORE: New Recycling Rules in England Limit Household Waste to Four Containers, Ban 39 Items
Another concern is the heavy reliance on informal observations made during assessments. These observations often capture only a single moment and can be influenced by superficial impressions rather than comprehensive clinical evidence. One claimant recounted how wearing makeup to feel confident during their assessment was misinterpreted as managing well, negatively impacting their claim.
Barrett stresses the need for a more compassionate and nuanced approach. “The DWP must move beyond the inflexible 50% rule and consider whether individuals can sustainably perform activities over time. Additionally, reducing the emphasis on subjective informal observations would make assessments fairer.”
With the Timms Review underway, this moment presents a crucial opportunity to overhaul PIP and make it more supportive for those with invisible disabilities. The MS Society has launched the campaign Fairness. Dignity. Respect. to push for these much-needed reforms and ensure the system truly serves those it is meant to help.