This weekend, Birmingham will once again be the stage for a political demonstration as supporters of Britain First gather in the city.
As editor of BirminghamLive, I have spent years hearing directly from residents across our region. I’ve listened to the frustrations of people witnessing rapid changes in their communities, those meeting the rising cost of living with anxiety, individuals grappling with shrinking public services and growing NHS waiting lists, and young people uncertain if homeownership will ever be within reach.
These concerns are genuine and deserve attention.
READ MORE: How Aston Villa Can Raise £120m for Transfers Without Selling Morgan Rogers
READ MORE: Closure Confirmed at Birmingham Bullring as New Brand Prepares to Move In
In a democracy, it is absolutely legitimate to question immigration policy, to scrutinize government planning for population growth, and to express feelings of being unheard or overlooked—whether in Birmingham, the Black Country, or elsewhere in the UK.
Citizens must have the right to voice these concerns openly and peacefully. Healthy democracies depend on it.
However, while the concerns themselves are valid, Britain First’s approach is not. There is a vital difference between critiquing policy and vilifying entire communities — a distinction that matters profoundly in Birmingham.
Our city is among Europe’s most diverse. According to the latest census, Birmingham is now a majority-minority city with no single ethnic group constituting more than half the population. Our schools, workplaces, neighborhoods, and places of worship are testaments to generations of migration and cultural exchange.
Most Birmingham residents, regardless of race, faith, or background, are simply striving to build decent lives for their families.
This is why I approach the upcoming rally with concern.
History shows that far-right demonstrations rarely remain confined to policy discussions. Debate on immigration can quickly sour into attacks on whole communities. What starts as criticism of immigration can devolve into hostility targeting ethnic minorities and Muslims. Political protests can attract those whose grievances are not with policies but with people.
That is worrying for us all.
Because the truth about modern Birmingham is that people from diverse backgrounds share many of the same challenges.
Walk through Small Heath, Erdington, Kingstanding, Sparkbrook, Northfield, or Handsworth, and you will meet families worried about bills, parents anxious over school places and healthcare, workers facing job insecurity, and pensioners struggling with energy costs.
Poverty does not discriminate by skin color.
The cost of living crisis affects us all, irrespective of religion.
Lack of opportunity hits every community.
None of these problems are solved by blaming another struggling group for your hardships.
In fact, Birmingham’s most deprived areas are home to diverse communities living side by side, all confronting economic challenges together.
The responsibility we have—politicians and citizens alike—is to address these realities honestly and constructively. It is crucial to engage in debate without losing sight of the humanity we share.
So, by all means, question immigration policy. Demand better public services. Hold those in power accountable.
But don’t turn on your neighbor. Don’t let ethnicity, religion, or nationality become scapegoats for economic hardship. And don’t allow legitimate concerns to be twisted into prejudice.
Birmingham has never been a perfect city. But it has thrived not by division, but through unity.
As demonstrators and counter-demonstrators take to the streets this weekend, let us remember that real solutions can only come from standing together—not tearing each other apart.