Birmingham’s newest one-way traffic system, introduced as part of the City Centre Movement and Access Strategy, aimed to reduce congestion by discouraging through traffic on inner-city roads. However, local businesses and drivers are now reporting significant traffic chaos and frustration, suggesting the intended relief has instead created new challenges.
Anthony Harfield, who has operated ADH Automotive near the Digbeth/Highgate border for 18 years, described the situation as nothing short of a nightmare. Since the one-way streets were introduced on Birchall Street and Cheapside, traffic regularly snarls in the evenings, with vehicles caught in prolonged queues and many drivers forced to navigate the wrong way down one-way streets out of confusion or desperation to escape the jams.
Harfield shared videos illustrating the daily gridlock, highlighting lorries and cars repeatedly going against traffic rules in attempts to reach their destinations. “I’ve never seen such chaos in my 25 years in the city,” he said. The new system has led some customers to avoid his garage entirely or endure lengthy detours, with some traveling miles around just to reach a business located mere yards away.
READ MORE: Sex Worker’s Nightmare: Married Birmingham Businessman’s Violent Assault Unveiled
READ MORE: Parking enforcement must precede bus priority measures on major Birmingham route, say councillors
“Birmingham’s traffic plan is well-intented but poorly planned,” Harfield argues. “Dividing the city into zones and forcing vehicles to use the ring road to traverse between them only overloads that road, causing near standstills. Local construction traffic struggles badly, and incorrect signage breeds further confusion.”
The council’s strategy limits private vehicles from traveling directly between city centre zones, encouraging public transport and active travel modes instead. While all locations remain accessible, private cars must approach areas from the ring road, a change outlined to improve air quality and pedestrian safety.
Nevertheless, Harfield and fellow business owners feel the plan neglects practical realities. Many local deliveries are hampered by the one-way loops and bus gates, which are often disregarded due to their impracticality. Harfield believes relocating the scheme to more residential areas like Bradford Street might ease the impact.
Ongoing construction and National Grid works compound the traffic woes, leading some emergency responders, police included, to find navigating the area nearly impossible. Harfield recalled an incident last year where fire engines struggled to reach a blaze next to the Islamic Relief warehouse due to the traffic layout.
Despite complaints, Birmingham City Council regards current congestion as a temporary “bedding-in period” as drivers adjust. A spokesperson reaffirmed that emergency access remains fully protected and emphasized the scheme’s long-term goals: safer streets, reduced congestion in neighbourhoods, and more reliable public transport.
While the council stands by the scheme’s vision for a cleaner, safer, and less car-dependent city centre, local business owners like Harfield fear the ongoing difficulties will stifle growth and suffocate vital commerce unless urgent adjustments are made.